Dr. Sudoku Prescribes #88 – Consecutive Sudoku

0 Flares Filament.io 0 Flares ×

Consecutive Sudoku by Thomas Snyder

PDF

Theme: Walls.

Rules: Standard Consecutive Sudoku rules.

Answer String: Enter the 2nd column from top to bottom, followed by a comma, followed by the 8th column from top to bottom.

Time Standards (highlight to view): Grandmaster = 3:15, Master = 5:00, Expert = 10:00

  • Aaron Chan says:

    I must have used a rather unconventional break in, seeing how I worked out A and B with nearly all of the center 3 columns empty. What I ended up doing was to deduce which numbers must form a consecutive pair, and write down those pairs on the side. The set of pairs chain pretty well once you get enough of them out, and the whole thing worked before I did much of anything in the center.

    • drsudoku drsudoku says:

      This is a puzzle where the three vertical chutes can solve somewhat independently. I didn’t feel like choosing an extra entry bit, and I liked the chained pairs on the outside more than the “standard” middle when I had to make a choice.

  • Rog says:

    Noticeable structure of the solved grid mod 3. Was that forced by the theme, chosen intentionally, or neither?

    • drsudoku drsudoku says:

      I’d definitely say this is a consequence of the design of bars. I tested the pattern more broadly and find only 168 solutions to this grid, all with this structure.

      There are a lot of hard to see constraints in making consecutive puzzles which often leads to oddities like this (well, frequently this specific oddity) — and also why a lot of consecutive puzzles have imperfect themes in the bars as you can’t avoid pairs very frequently. I first learned this the hard way when Wei-Hwa gave me a 7 given non-consecutive puzzle while working on Mutant Sudoku that I could do absolutely nothing with.

      • Tom Collyer says:

        I was going to say something along the same lines. Getting a valid solution out of an a priori nice looking consecutive puzzle is a massively constrained challenge. I suppose I’m not surprised that getting something to fit required the help of a computer search, and this is one of the reasons i’m teaching myself to program. Highly customised generators do have a place in sudoku!

        • drsudoku drsudoku says:

          My construction style varies a lot based on type but I probably use code the most nowadays with this style of sudoku. Nothing wrong with tools as long as a human is still guiding the end-result.

          Specifically, with consecutives I check if a pattern has any solutions (and a sense of how many) before I try to build anything. Here there really were not a lot of choices, so after specifying a couple digits (even fewer than these 16) you can have a finished puzzle. I remember wanting to make a smiley face for Mutant Sudoku and checking about 16 different patterns for a clean puzzle. Only one of the 16 smiles, a particularly evil looking one, had any solutions at all.

  • Ours brun says:

    1’50, starting with the central columns – but looking at the puzzle again I see that the horizontal option was a good one too (although maybe not as fast). A bit surprised by the target times here since I found the puzzle really easy. Do you have an idea of which path had the favor of your test-solvers?

    • drsudoku drsudoku says:

      I actually removed some givens after my first test and likely overcompensated on the overall time. I could probably stand to have a few more sudoku specialists as testers as I almost always base the grandmaster time on what I think I would have taken myself, which I don’t need to do with any of the puzzle times.

  • skynet says:

    4’14” – Beautiful sudoku motris!!!!Loved the solve path.Would want this sudoku season to continue more.Thnks for the nice sudoku

  • hagriddler says:

    I wanted to ask about an oddity vertical in each block in the solved grid but I guess that is the same as mentioned above as ‘mod 3’… Nice & easy !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.