The Doctor is In?!?

So last week was a week at sea for the solvers with Battleships and Battleship Sudoku. It was also my first week at SEA(ttle). And while it already feels like home I have a lot of apartment set-up to do still, and a growing pile of work as I take time to buy and build furniture.

My most observant solvers may have noticed I’ve been following particular genres in YRBGW order so far with my puzzle styles. If you don’t know what I mean, search the website a bit more. But I hate being predictable. I wrote a championship “Trophy” sudoku puzzle once with a first row ?2345678?. My occasional partner in puzzle-solving crime, Wei-Hwa Huang, saw that pattern and thought it was as likely that I would do 923456781 in a competition as 123456789 just to be sneaky. This week, I’ve decided I’ll just flip a coin to determine what I’ll post of the remaining options so you can’t possibly know better than 50:50 what puzzle type is coming. Or maybe that last sentence is a lie. Or maybe every other sentence in this paragraph is a lie. In all honesty, there are no hidden puzzles in this paragraph. But there are two more puzzle styles to come this week: a familiar sudoku style from me and Wei-Hwa, and whichever of “heads” or “tails” wins the coin toss today.

This week I’m going to start hiding the solving times behind a spoiler tag. I don’t know how choosing to see these times before starting will affect your solving, but I’d welcome a discussion on how times, or “points” on a competitive test, change your solving style. Does this differ when you have hand-crafted puzzles with a particular time goal versus, say, a generated croco-puzzle with a particular time standard set from other solvers?

  • Scott Handelman says:

    *scans most of the site*

    Nope, still don’t know what YRBGW style is…

  • Jack Bross says:

    I suspect hiding the time goals on this site won’t matter to me, since I don’t really race on solving them. Croco-Puzzle is another matter, though, where everything counts towards a score. If I see a puzzle with times around 30 seconds, I know it’s a “sprint/blitz” puzzle where I should just look for obvious stuff and not worry about any subtlety. If I see a puzzle with times around 5-10 minutes, I know that things like pencil marks and careful “feeling out the puzzle” are in order.

    Also, I would note that even without formal times to shoot for, the progressive difficulty through the week on this site could function the same way. With no time, I’d tend to blast through a Monday puzzle and be a bit more cautious on a Friday/Saturday puzzle.

    (The real question on CrocoPuzzle for me is how much I can slash time off without risking a Fehlversuch on those quick puzzles – recklessness can really hurt)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.